Resources / Operations
Managed IT vs in-house IT for law firms: when does hiring make sense?
Sometimes a full-time hire is the right answer. Here's the honest comparison — costs, cover, expertise — including the cases where we'd tell a firm to hire internally.
The “should we hire in-house or use a managed IT firm?” question is asked a lot, and most answers are either self-serving (managed IT firms saying “use us”) or romanticised (firms imagining a single brilliant IT manager who’ll solve everything). Neither is right.
This article gives the honest comparison, including the cases where we’d tell a firm to hire internally rather than work with us.
What a managed IT firm gives you
A reputable managed IT firm gives you:
- A team of people, with overlapping skills, available across business hours and on-call out-of-hours
- 24×7 Security Operations Centre cover (almost impossible to replicate in-house under 200 staff)
- Tools and platforms that wouldn’t be cost-effective for a single firm (RMM, MDR, ticketing, audit tooling, vCIO software)
- A vCIO presence at the partners’ table
- Continuous Technology Alignment review against industry standards
- Compliance posture (Cyber Essentials, ISO 27001 alignment, SRA expectations) baked in
- Continuity when individuals are on holiday or leave
The headline cost for a UK law firm is £100 to £150 per user per month, plus software licences and hardware. There is a fuller breakdown of what managed IT support includes for a law firm and what it should cost if you want to check either side of the comparison.
What an in-house IT person gives you
A full-time IT manager gives you:
- Someone who works for your firm, in your office, with your culture
- Deep familiarity with your specific environment, software stack, and people
- Same-day responsiveness on minor issues — fee-earners can walk over to the IT desk
- A single internal voice for IT decisions
- Capacity for project work without separate quotes
The headline cost for a UK law firm in London or the Home Counties is £55,000 to £75,000 fully loaded for a capable IT manager. A junior support hire is £30,000 to £40,000.
Where managed IT wins
For firms under approximately 80 staff:
- You can’t afford the redundancy. A single IT manager goes on holiday. Gets ill. Quits with two weeks’ notice. Your firm depends on technology — you cannot have one person be the single point of failure for it.
- You can’t justify the toolset. The tools a managed IT firm uses (security operations platform, MDR, vCIO software, network monitoring, backup-and-restore at scale) cost more per year than a junior IT salary. Multi-tenanted across many firms, the unit cost is reasonable. Single-tenanted, it isn’t.
- You’d have to pick a generalist. Below 80 staff, you can hire one person. That person will be a competent generalist — they will not be a deep specialist in security, networking, M365 administration, and practice-management integration. A managed IT firm has each of those people.
- Compliance posture is hard to maintain. Cyber Essentials, ISO 27001, SRA expectations — these need continuous attention by people who do them across many environments. A solo in-house manager will let some slip; not from incompetence, just from bandwidth.
Where in-house wins
For firms over approximately 250 staff:
- The economics flip. At 250 staff, the marginal cost of additional managed IT users exceeds what an in-house team would cost. You can hire two or three people for what 250 users at £125/month per user buys you.
- Internal politics matter more. A 250-person firm has internal coalitions, change-resistant fee-earners, and entrenched ways of working. An external IT firm has limited authority to push through change. An internal CIO has more.
- Specialist roles become viable. At 250 staff you can justify a security specialist, a M365 administrator, an applications person, and an IT manager. Below that, you’re hoping one person does all four.
The middle ground: 80-250 staff
Most firms in this range benefit from both. The right model is usually:
- One in-house IT person — typically titled IT Manager — handling day-to-day user support, internal advocacy, and project coordination.
- A managed IT firm providing infrastructure operations, security operations centre cover, vCIO strategy, and continuous alignment review.
The in-house person is the firm’s voice; the managed IT firm is the depth and the cover. The two together are meaningfully better than either alone, at this size.
For Techsperience clients in this range, we work alongside the in-house IT manager rather than around them. The vCIO sessions are joint sessions. The alignment review surfaces gaps the in-house person can prioritise. The 24×7 SOC means the in-house person can take a holiday.
When we’d tell a firm to hire instead
The honest answer:
- You’re growing past 250 staff and don’t have an internal IT lead yet. Hire one. We’ll be the team that sits behind them.
- You have a specific compliance overlay we don’t have depth in. If your firm has a regulatory profile that needs daily, deep specialist attention — not just SRA-grade controls — an in-house specialist is the right answer.
- You’ve had a managed IT relationship that didn’t work, and the diagnosis is fundamentally cultural. Sometimes the answer is “we need someone in our office, on our payroll, in our culture.” A managed IT firm cannot replace that, however good.
If any of those describe your situation, we’d say so on the 10-minute call. We’d rather not start a relationship that ends in eighteen months because the underlying need was different.
How to think about the decision
Two questions, in order:
- Below 80 staff? Managed IT is the right default. Solo in-house hire is almost always the wrong call.
- 80 to 250 staff? Managed IT plus one in-house person is the right default. Pure in-house is fragile; pure managed IT misses internal advocacy.
- Over 250 staff? Internal team plus managed IT for specialist depth (SOC, vCIO, peer benchmarking) is increasingly common. Pure managed IT is unusual at this size; pure in-house leaves specialist gaps.
The wrong decision is rarely the choice of model. It’s underestimating the level of investment required, then trying to make whichever model you picked work on a 70%-of-needed budget.
One more thing that has changed the arithmetic since we first wrote this: AI tooling. Rolling out Copilot or a legal AI product safely is a security and data-governance job before it is a productivity one, and it is exactly the kind of specialist, occasional work that a solo in-house generalist will not have done before. If AI is on your firm’s agenda, weight that in favour of having a team behind you, whichever model you choose. Our AI Readiness Check is a reasonable way to see how much of that work is ahead of you.
Frequently asked
Common questions on this topic.
When should a law firm hire in-house IT?
Most firms over 100 fee-earners benefit from at least one in-house IT person, typically as an IT manager working alongside a managed IT firm. Firms over 250 fee-earners may justify a full in-house team. Below 80 fee-earners, in-house IT is usually more expensive and less effective than managed IT.
How much does an in-house IT manager cost?
For a law firm in London or the Home Counties, expect £55,000 to £75,000 per year fully loaded (salary + employer NI + pension + benefits) for a capable IT manager. A junior IT support role lands at £30,000 to £40,000 fully loaded.
Can in-house IT and managed IT coexist?
Yes — and for firms over 80-100 fee-earners, this is usually the right model. The in-house person handles day-to-day user support and acts as the internal IT voice; the managed IT firm provides infrastructure, security, vCIO strategy, and 24×7 monitoring.
What does managed IT for a law firm actually include?
A helpdesk that owns problems end to end, Microsoft 365 and device management, patching, email security, endpoint protection and 24×7 security monitoring, backup and recovery, and — in a good contract — a continuous review of the environment against a standard plus quarterly strategy time with the partners. It is delivered for a fixed monthly fee per user, which is what makes it easy to compare against a salary.
Related reading